Shielding Gas Effect on Dendrite-Reinforced Composite Bronze Coatings via WAAM Cladding: Minimizing Defects and Intergranular Bronze Penetration into 09G2S Steel

Abstract

Bronze materials are indispensable across numerous industries for enhancing the durability and performance of components, primarily due to their excellent tribological properties, corrosion resistance, and machinability. This study investigates the impact of different atmospheric conditions on the properties of WAAM (wire arc additive manufacturing) cladded bronze coatings on 09G2S steel substrate. Specifically, the research examines how varying atmospheres—including ambient air (N<inf>2</inf>/O<inf>2</inf>, no shielding gas), pure argon (Ar), carbon dioxide (CO<inf>2</inf>), and 82% Ar + 18% CO<inf>2</inf> (Ar/CO<inf>2</inf>) mixture—influence coating defectiveness (porosity, cracks, non-uniformity), wettability (manifested as uniform layer formation and strong adhesion), and the extent of intergranular penetration (IGP), leading to the formation of characteristic infiltrated cracks or “bronze whiskers”. Modern investigative techniques such as optical microscopy (OM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS), and X-ray diffraction (XRD) were employed for comprehensive material characterization. Microhardness testing was also carried out to evaluate and confirm the homogeneity of the coating structure. The findings revealed that the bronze coatings primarily consisted of a dominant, highly textured FCC α-Cu phase and a minor BCC α-Fe phase, with Rietveld refinement quantifying a α-Fe volume fraction of ~5%, lattice parameters of a = 0.3616 nm for α-Cu and a = 0.2869 nm for α-Fe, and a modest microstrain of 0.001. The bronze coating deposited under a pure Ar atmosphere exhibited superior performance, characterized by excellent wettability, a uniform, near-defect-free structure with minimal porosity and cracks, and significantly suppressed formation of bronze whiskers, both in quantity and size. Conversely, the coating deposited without a protective atmosphere demonstrated the highest degree of defectiveness, including agglomerated pores and cracks, leading to an uneven interface and extensive whisker growth of varied morphologies. Microhardness tests confirmed that while the Ar-atmosphere coating displayed the lowest hardness (~130 HV<inf>0.1</inf>), it maintained consistent values across the entire analyzed area, indicating structural homogeneity. These results underscore the critical role of atmosphere selection in WAAM processing for achieving high-quality bronze coatings with enhanced interfacial integrity and functional performance. © 2025 by the authors.